2018 Jim Park Voting Rd 20: Carlton vs GWS

[crashlander]

Remember:
[1] At least 3 players need to get a mention.
[2] No more than 10 votes for any one player.
[3] Give a rating of team performance. It can be anywhere from A+ to F.
[4] Votes must add up to 15.

I didn't see anything of last week's game.  :-[ But I'll be there this week. Hopefully there are more vote worthy rather than cringe worthy performances.

[crashlander]

Why do I have to see this week's game and not last week?

Oh well.

Team: F
Very ordinary, even though we were playing a good team going places.

Votes:
[4] Paddy Cripps
[3.5] Harry McKay
[1.5] Marc Murphy
[1] Ciaran Byrne
[1] Daisy Thomas
[1] Matthew Lobbe
[1] Sam Petrevski-Seton
[1] Jed Lamb
[0.5] Charlie Curnow
[0.5] Ed Curnow

Explanations:
[4] Paddy Cripps: 29 possessions when out midfield is smashed and getting scragged every time he got near the ball, Crippa is a marvel. 9 tackles as well.
[3.5] Harry McKay: H was simply too good for the GWS defence. He took 8 great marks and should have had 5 goals, as he missed the 2 easy ones. He looked to be the future.
[1.5] Marc Murphy: Tried hard.
[1] Ciaran Byrne: Coming back to some form, Casey really showed some great tackling and run.
[1] Daisy Thomas: Took out Greene in a very solid effort.
[1] Matthew Lobbe: Tried hard, but really showed his limitations.
[1] Sam Petrevski-Seton: Playing in defence was good for SPS, as he looked pretty good.
[1] Jed Lamb: A very solid effort in defence.
[0.5] Charlie Curnow: Looked dangerous, but dropped some marks he should have swallowed.
[0.5] Ed Curnow: Tried hard.

Honourable Mentions:
Sam Rowe: Did a decent job in defence, everything considered.
Matthew Wright: Tried hard and managed 2 good goals.
Caleb Marchbank: Took Lobb to the cleaners, but couldn’t provide a lot of run.
Cameron Polson: Not enough, but he did manage some very good things. His pressure was good, but his kicking and decision making need work

[RiverRat]

Team = F


[4]  McKay
[3]  Cripps
[2]  Thomas
[2]  Petrevski-Seton
[1]  Murphy
[1]  Marchbank
[1]  Lobbe
[1]  Dow

[madbluboy]

F

7 McKay
7 Thomas
1 Cripps

[shawny]

Team F

Cripps 4
Harry 4
Daisy 3
Rowe 2

[Thryleon]

N/A

6 McKay
6 Thomas
2 Cripps
1 Charlie Curnow

[Baggers]

Team F-


4 - McKay

4 - Thomas

3 - Cripps

1 - Dow

1 - Lobbe

1 - Murphy

1 - SPS

HM: Lamb, Marchbank.

[ElwoodBlues1]

Team F:

6: Thomas
3: Cripps
3: Mckay
1: Dow
1: Simpson
1: Marchbank

[deepbluesee]

Team F

As for the individuals - not a case of who was good - more just who wasn't bad
Cripps 3
Mckay 3
Simpson 2
Byrne 1
Marchbank 1
Rowe 1
Polson 1
Ed Curnow 1
Murphy 1
Lobbe 1

[DJC]

Team: F-

5 - McKay
4 - Cripps
3 - Thomas
2 - Petrevski-Seton
1 - Murphy

HMs - Dow, Rowe and Marchbank