AFL Rd 24 2024 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs St, Kilda

[Gointocarlton]

You forgot the Brizvegas guy that came the year Judd did, Richard Hadley ?

Nah he's there. Cam OShea was the one I forgot

[sleeper]

Andrew Collins
Jason Tutt

[tonyo]

Here's an interesting thought about Sunday's game.....

After all the tears and disappointment, the only actual outcome of the day's events was that St Kilda moved from Pick 5 in the draft to Pick 7.

So, as they say in the classics, who actually won?

[Thryleon]

Here's an interesting thought about Sunday's game.....

After all the tears and disappointment, the only actual outcome of the day's events was that St Kilda moved from Pick 5 in the draft to Pick 7.

So, as they say in the classics, who actually won?

They did.  Shows we were the only crap truck team to tie their on field fortune to the draft and paid for it by breeding a culture of not winning.

[Shakin77]

You forgot the Brizvegas guy that came the year Judd did, Richard Hadley ?

Hads was a good player.  Knees were shot.

[Gointocarlton]

Andrew Collins
Jason Tutt

Fair pair there.

[PaulP]

You'd have to wonder whether the failure of those players mentioned was more development or recruiting.

[deepbluesee]

You'd have to wonder whether the failure of those players mentioned was more development or recruiting.

I have believed for a long time that development coach/team is every bit as important as the match day stuff. Also, it is much easier to develop in a strong side with a good culture than in a weak one - better physical and mental support on match day, on the training track and just around the club.

[PaulP]

I have believed for a long time that development coach/team is every bit as important as the match day stuff. Also, it is much easier to develop in a strong side with a good culture than in a weak one - better physical and mental support on match day, on the training track and just around the club.

Yes, i completely agree.

[Gointocarlton]

You'd have to wonder whether the failure of those players mentioned was more development or recruiting.

I tend to think back in those days it was very poor recruiting (both at ND and Trade). We seemed to land players that no one else wanted. When I think of development, I tend to think of the kids or less experienced blokes. Some of the ones in the lists were experienced guys who were brought with a view for them to fill a role. They were either hacks or passed it. Just my view.