Post Game Permutation: AFL Rd 12: Carlton vs Fremantle

[RiverRat]

Really like Cottrell's run and pace.  Reminds me of Phil Maylin with the buzz cut and running style.

I thought he looked like a dead ringer for Mitch Robinson during his celebration.

[Micky0]

Really? What was his contribution? Jesus, we win a game with no help from the "human impediment to winning", and you make out like he kicked the winning goal.

Did you even watch the game? LOL

Yawn.

[Spanner_smf2_import2]

Yawn.

Yes, quite

[Micky0]

Really? What was his contribution? Jesus, we win a game with no help from the "human impediment to winning", and you make out like he kicked the winning goal.

Did you even watch the game? LOL

What positives do you see? Or do you just sweat out a game wondering what Murphy will provide? Sad if so, other guys to watch and get excited about the CFC About.

[Spanner_smf2_import2]

What positives do you see? Or do you just sweat out a game wondering what Murphy will provide? Sad if so, other guys to watch and get excited about the CFC About.

Nah, just sick of people making excuses for the newly named "human impediment to winning".

Every time some one posts something positive he does, I'll be there as the counter weight to make sure both sides of the story are told.

We're not going to have a Trump type narrative concerning the HITW.

[townsendcalling]

Really? What was his contribution? Jesus, we win a game with no help from the "human impediment to winning", and you make out like he kicked the winning goal.

Did you even watch the game? LOL

Yep, sure did,
And so did the Herald Sun:
Carlton: Curnow, Cripps, Walsh, Murphy, Setterfield, Cottrell

And the Carlton Website:
Carlton: Curnow, Cripps, Walsh, Docherty, Murphy, Setterfield

And The Age:
Carlton: Walsh, Cripps, E Curnow, Casboult, Murphy, Newnes

And the AFL Website:
Carlton: Curnow, Cripps, Walsh, Docherty, Murphy, Setterfield

And Spanner:
Cripps is becoming a liability. Someone's been reading their own press me thinks. (Contribution?  24 disposals, 20 contested, 6 tackles, 4 centre clearances)
The power house Murphy led midfield is getting annihilated by a couple of 50 gamers. (Brayshaw, Cerra, Munday, Serong and Ffyfe all had less disposals, less centre clearances and only Ffyfe had more contested possessions. Collectively they had 1 centre clearances between them!!)
Nice work Marc, nice work (Contribution?  20 disposals, 13 contested, 3 tackles, 2 centre clearances)

Now that's where the LOL belongs!!! (BTW, sorry to disappoint you, but WE WON!!)

[ElwoodBlues1]

Thought Curnow played a very good game and kept us in the game when it was tough early.Cottrell is so much like a young Robbo in looks and played another handy game.
Cripps improved as the game went on and we got helped by Longmuir taking Fyfe out of the midfield after he was slaughtering us.. really strange move and Freo lost their way after that. Walsh was very good in the 2nd half and played a mature game. TDK  soldiered on vs some tough opposition and Honey looked the part all be it briefly.
Newnes had played a shocker but delivered when it mattered..
Yep Freo got robbed at the end but luck usually comes and goes and they will get their turn of luck like we did somewhere down the track... Would love to beat Collingwood with the last kick, feel it was wasted on rubbish like Freo, they really really are a hack team. If D'Arcy praised Luke Ryan one more time the TV was going out the window, commentary was just rubbish..

[laj]

This would be right...lol.

[PaulP]

A for effort, and Newnes may well be a hero, but that was an appalling game of football. Appalling commentary, appalling umpiring and appalling skills from both teams. As bad as the R4 2019 game last year, except we miraculously managed to be on right side of the ledger this time.

Bank the 4 points, erase the game from the hard drive, and pray to God we never serve up that drivel again.

[BluePhantom]

So glad I didn't watch it due to the poor umpiring again.
Watched the replay and I am a bit concerned about McKay and his percieved casualness.
That last shot on goal by Harry, he showed no composure, no will to take control. He didn't even look at the goals.
I want our FF to take control and demand the ball, want to kick these types of goals.
He has no routine, needs to talk to Fev.
1 or 2 goal a game player he shouldn't be. It needs to be 3 or 4 +.
Awesome kick by Newnes but I also love the never say die attitude Teague has got going.