Post Game Participation: AFL Rd 11: Carlton vs West Coast

[Gointocarlton]

Interesting “Access All Areas” on the AFL website today. Examines and compares 6 “holding the ball” scenarios that ALL went against Carlton. The only consistency was ruling against the Blues. Better not watch it Baggers because it will make your blood boil.

Here's my point of view on yesterday's game, despite the terrible umpiring against us, I was a lot more calm during and after the game compared to the Haw game the week before. We took it right up to a contender and if not for a poor 10-15mins, we would have won.

[Lods]

With all these blokes going forward we won't have many left in the Midfield/backline. ;D  ;D  ;D  ;D

But you know, if we ever reach the stage  where the seasons done and dusted for us, and if we had a tall back-up defender I wouldn't mind seeing Jones switched to the forward line for a bit of an experiment.
The reasoning is... we could do with a tall swingman who could play both ends.
We struggle with responses at the moment when the opposition gets a run on.
We need to develop a few tricks of our own

You would know in a game or two whether Jones has learnt a bit playing on some of the competitions best forwards.
His marking on the weekend was strong ...and we finally have a few small forwards who might be able to make something of the chaos he sometimes creates.

It may be that he proves to be as ineffective as his previous stints forward but if we've nothing  to lose give it a go.

[Gointocarlton]

With all these blokes going forward we won't have many left in the Midfield/backline. ;D  ;D  ;D  ;D

But you know, if we ever reach the stage  where the seasons done and dusted for us, and if we had a tall back-up defender I wouldn't mind seeing Jones switched to the forward line for a bit of an experiment.
The reasoning is... we could do with a tall swingman who could play both ends.
We struggle with responses at the moment when the opposition gets a run on.
We need to develop a few tricks of our own

You would know in a game or two whether Jones has learnt a bit playing on some of the competitions best forwards.
His marking on the weekend was strong ...and we finally have a few small forwards who might be able to make something of the chaos he sometimes creates.

It may be that he proves to be as ineffective as his previous stints forward but if we've nothing  to lose give it a go.

The season is over, we would need to win 5 of the next 7 plus other results go our way, aint gonna happen so experiment away I say.

[Gointocarlton]

With all these blokes going forward we won't have many left in the Midfield/backline. ;D  ;D  ;D  ;D

But you know, if we ever reach the stage  where the seasons done and dusted for us, and if we had a tall back-up defender I wouldn't mind seeing Jones switched to the forward line for a bit of an experiment.
The reasoning is... we could do with a tall swingman who could play both ends.
We struggle with responses at the moment when the opposition gets a run on.
We need to develop a few tricks of our own

You would know in a game or two whether Jones has learnt a bit playing on some of the competitions best forwards.
His marking on the weekend was strong ...and we finally have a few small forwards who might be able to make something of the chaos he sometimes creates.

It may be that he proves to be as ineffective as his previous stints forward but if we've nothing  to lose give it a go.

As for Jones going fwd, I dont think effort, endeavour or marking the thing will be a problem, I think his kicking for goal would be a problem

[Lods]

As for Jones going fwd, I dont think effort, endeavour or marking the thing will be a problem, I think his kicking for goal would be a problem

You may be right...I'm probably thinking more about the opportunities he could create for players like Betts, Fisher and Martin.
And going ahead you would see it more a 'switch' role.
Something you would try mid-game if you needed to shake things up.
He's not SOS....but it was a tactic we used to try with Silvagni at times, often with success.
McGovern v Jones...I'm not sure we'd lose a lot.

[ElwoodBlues1]

With all these blokes going forward we won't have many left in the Midfield/backline. ;D  ;D  ;D  ;D

But you know, if we ever reach the stage  where the seasons done and dusted for us, and if we had a tall back-up defender I wouldn't mind seeing Jones switched to the forward line for a bit of an experiment.
The reasoning is... we could do with a tall swingman who could play both ends.
We struggle with responses at the moment when the opposition gets a run on.
We need to develop a few tricks of our own

You would know in a game or two whether Jones has learnt a bit playing on some of the competitions best forwards.
His marking on the weekend was strong ...and we finally have a few small forwards who might be able to make something of the chaos he sometimes creates.

It may be that he proves to be as ineffective as his previous stints forward but if we've nothing  to lose give it a go.

I subscribe to the "if it aint broke dont fix it" with Jones, dont want to play him forward then he loses it and goes back to the old flaky Jones.
Your swingman is Kemp....great mark and nice kick...

[Gointocarlton]

You may be right...I'm probably thinking more about the opportunities he could create for players like Betts, Fisher and Martin.
And going ahead you would see it more a 'switch' role.
Something you would try mid-game if you needed to shake things up.
He's not SOS....but it was a tactic we used to try with Silvagni at times, often with success.
McGovern v Jones...I'm not sure we'd lose a lot.

Fair call

[Micky0]

Here's my point of view on yesterday's game, despite the terrible umpiring against us, I was a lot more calm during and after the game compared to the Haw game the week before. We took it right up to a contender and if not for a poor 10-15mins, we would have won.

I felt the same. Realised it was because we weren’t expected to win, yet Hawks game talked up all week that we would ?

[Thryleon]

Opposite for me.  I was extremely annoyed with our inability to be effectie last week but half expected it.

The West coast game felt very much like we were expected to play with one hand behind our back, and I couldn't help but think this isn't  fair contest and not because West coast were a better side.

[Micky0]

Opposite for me.  I was extremely annoyed with our inability to be effectie last week but half expected it.

The West coast game felt very much like we were expected to play with one hand behind our back, and I couldn't help but think this isn't  fair contest and not because West coast were a better side.

I agree about us getting a hard ride. It’s frustrating, we just want to watch an evenly officiated game.  The stats speak for themselves and we deserve an explanation.

How Curnows was deliberate, when he was up against the boundary and kicked 50m in and it then dribbled out, is just an illogical ridiculous call.

I can’t Believe umpires care who wins or try to help someone win, but something is not right with the way our games are officiated.