2018 Rd 20: Post Game Calm & Civilized Discussion: Carlton vs GWS

[crashlander]

I don't expect the same feeling as last week, but I can hope.

[PaulP]

I don't expect the same feeling as last week, but I can hope.

Your thread title needs to be spell checked.

[crashlander]

Your thread title needs to be spell checked.

There are times when mu entire brain needs a spell check. 

[PaulP]

There are times when mu entire brain needs a spell check. 

I kno the feeeelling whell.

[kruddler]

So before people start questioning why player x is getting a game, i thought i'd copy this from what i wrote in the in-game thread.

@Prof....

Injury list heading into this game...
David Cuningham Hamstring Season
Jesse Glass-McCasker Knee 2 weeks
Sam Docherty* Knee Season
Zac Fisher Leg Season
Liam Jones Knee Season
Matthew Kreuzer Heart Test
Kym LeBois Hamstring 4 weeks
Cillian McDaid Foot 1 week
Andrew Phillips Hamstring Season
Lachie Plowman Knee Season
Alex Silvagni Achilles Season
Jacob Weitering Quad Test
Tom Williamson Back

Add in J. Silvagni who was a late out with injury

14 players.

We are (obviously) playing 22 today.

That makes 36.

That leaves 9 players who are not on either of those 2 lists.
1. Casboult
2. Kerridge
3. Mullett
4. Shaw
5. Schumacher
6. De Koning
7. Macreadie
8. Garlett
9. Kerr


Blokes not up to AFL standard
Kids who have been injured and play a position already taken by kids
Somewhere inbetween the 2 other categories.

So remind me....who exactly should we playing in place of Graham, Polson, Lang and whoever else you have an issue with?

[Lods]

Could be worse...we could support Gold Coast
Melb 57- GC 6 at quarter time.

There is something radically wrong with this competition.

[townsendcalling]

Could be worse...we could support Gold Coast
Melb 57- GC 6 at quarter time.

There is something radically wrong with this competition.

I DARE them not to apply for a priority pick.

[Gointocarlton]

Other than H and Crippa, I dont know what to take out of that. They were too fast, skilled, strong and smart. Kelly would have walked away from that thinking no way I will go to that club in a hurry. Souless and spiritless performance. The only stats we won were hit outs and bounces.

[LP]

Looking at the hybrid, half-arsed free agency is a big starting point!

Then they need to get some real control over the under the table payments.

[laj]

That last qtr was the most embarrassing since I started following footy 55 years ago. They were down to 17, even even 16.....16!!!!!!!!

We are so poorly structured, poorly drilled that we had no idea how to take advantage of that. what have we been doing for the last 3 years.