2018 Rd 6: Pre Game Paranoia: Carlton vs Western Bulldogs

[Rational_Expectations]

SPS may spend more time up forward this week

[laj]

In, defender and mid
Out, 2 forwards

??

I'm still wondering how O'Shea held his place.

[cookie2]

O'Shea given another go!

[ElwoodBlues1]

In, defender and mid
Out, 2 forwards

??

Garlett's omission is baffling IMO.....OShea very lucky to be retained although maybe while his disposal was RS perhaps he stopped his man and thats why he is still in.
Good to have Kennedy back, we look a bit bigger and stronger, maybe we are expecting a rough and tumble game from the equally desperate Dogs.
Very winnable IMO and will be interesting to see the tactics employed given both teams are struggling...men behind the ball or all out attack, reckon the former.....dont see it being pretty to watch...

[Gointocarlton]

Garlett's omission is baffling IMO.....OShea very lucky to be retained although maybe while his disposal was RS perhaps he stopped his man and thats why he is still in.
Good to have Kennedy back, we look a bit bigger and stronger, maybe we are expecting a rough and tumble game from the equally desperate Dogs.
Very winnable IMO and will be interesting to see the tactics employed given both teams are struggling...men behind the ball or all out attack, reckon the former.....dont see it being pretty to watch...

Ugly Win is better that a Pretty Loss.

[cookie2]

Garlett's omission is baffling IMO.....OShea very lucky to be retained although maybe while his disposal was RS perhaps he stopped his man and thats why he is still in.
Good to have Kennedy back, we look a bit bigger and stronger, maybe we are expecting a rough and tumble game from the equally desperate Dogs.
Very winnable IMO and will be interesting to see the tactics employed given both teams are struggling...men behind the ball or all out attack, reckon the former.....dont see it being pretty to watch...

Yep. Expect a dog-fight in fact.

[townsendcalling]

Marchbank might be a late test.  Don’t be surprised to see Shaw moved up if Caleb doesn’t make it. 

[kruddler]

Garlett's omission is baffling IMO.....OShea very lucky to be retained although maybe while his disposal was RS perhaps he stopped his man and thats why he is still in.
Good to have Kennedy back, we look a bit bigger and stronger, maybe we are expecting a rough and tumble game from the equally desperate Dogs.
Very winnable IMO and will be interesting to see the tactics employed given both teams are struggling...men behind the ball or all out attack, reckon the former.....dont see it being pretty to watch...

Agree re Garlett. Didn't have the best game, sure, but is a unique type player who we can't replace...and certainly didn't replace with those in's.

OShea must have some incriminating photos of someone. Not sure what he has done since getting in the side, last week (with potential concussion issues) he should've been given a 'rest' from the 1's.

I think last week has been the ONLY week all year where i've been happy with the team balance....and was probably our best effort for the year since R1. Thought we'd turned the corner there, but apprantly not.

Interestingly, Kerr not named in the emergencies this week. Missed his chance?

[crazyjoedevolamk11]

No Cunningham in emergencies either :o

[blue4life]

I'm still wondering how O'Shea held his place.

You and me both, he was woeful last week.