2017 Jim Park Voting: Rd 12: Carlton vs GWS

[mateinone]

Team A+

Knocking off the best team in the comp, who didn't play badly and who had some unbelievable pieces of play can only happen if a team commits for 100% of the game and sticks rigidly to their tasks. Amazing effort.
I could have given votes to pretty well most players to be fair.

6 Docherty - Is he now Carlton's best player? Amazing effort
5 Kreuzer - The other Blue who would have to be in serious AA contention.
2 Jones - He simply could not have had a better rebirth game imo, was incredible
0.5 Murphy
0.5 Gibbs
0.5 Plowman
0.5 Simmo

Apologies to all of the rest of the team

[Hubba]

A

5 Kreuzer
4 Docherty
3 Jones
2 Plowman
1 Cripps

First time in history a side sitting 17th on the ladder has beaten the team on top and some think its not an ' A ' grade performance.

[maxm68]

I gave us a  B+ for our missed goals...

we dominated the game but were lucky to hang on by a point in the end because we missed a lot of easy ones.... we should have put them away. 

That would have been an A or A+    IMO

[Vivian]

Team a

Docherty 4
Kreuzer 4
Murphy 2
Gibbs 1
Thomas 1
Jones 1
Wright 1
Cuningham 1

[blue4life]

Team A

4 Kreuzer
4 Docherty
3 Murphy
2 Gibbs
2 Jones