2017 Round 5: Post Game Prognostications: Carlton vs Port Adelaide

[LP]

I'd love to know how you'd do it. I really don't see any other way. Maybe you know John Elliot? Maybe you are John Elliot?????

We won't without aggressive trading or AFL help, don't hold you breath for AFL help.

The aggressive trading part is Cripps and Weitering, they are both worth two low draft picks each. Turn two aces into four, maybe, but you'd want to be confident of the draft and recruiter!

[Jofo]

We won't without aggressive trading or AFL help, don't hold you breath for AFL help.

The aggressive trading part is Cripps and Weitering, they are both worth two low draft picks each. Turn two aces into four, maybe, but you'd want to be confident of the draft and recruiter!

I think I'll stick with the current plan.

[Professer E]

Quality players are so hard to get that I wouldn't trade out the few we've got.  Even at 50% hit rate, chances are you'd break even - at best.

[cimm1979]

If he was 3 years younger I'd just about sell the farm for Robbie Gray.

[Mantis]

If he was 3 years younger I'd just about sell the farm for Robbie Gray.

They wouldn't take the deal.  ;D

[Boundaryrider]

We won't without aggressive trading or AFL help, don't hold you breath for AFL help.

The aggressive trading part is Cripps and Weitering, they are both worth two low draft picks each. Turn two aces into four, maybe, but you'd want to be confident of the draft and recruiter!

Potentially the stupidest direction the club could take. Read through the last 10 afl drafts and see how many gun top tens don't make it let alone become a gun

[flyboy77]

Potentially the stupidest direction the club could take. Read through the last 10 afl drafts and see how many gun top tens don't make it let alone become a gun

x2. Entirely pointless and entirely extremely high risk (with medium prospect of success).

In my world that equals stay the f... away from that deal.

[JonHenry]

We won't without aggressive trading or AFL help, don't hold you breath for AFL help.

The aggressive trading part is Cripps and Weitering, they are both worth two low draft picks each. Turn two aces into four, maybe, but you'd want to be confident of the draft and recruiter!

We love to make excuses for Gibbs and Murphy who have netted 2 B&Fs between them in almost 20 years of football, and you want to trade out the two future stars of the club?

????

[PaulP]

We love to make excuses for Gibbs and Murphy who have netted 2 B&Fs between them in almost 20 years of football, and you want to trade out the two future stars of the club?

????

Apart from seasons ruined by injury, they've both consistently been top 5 in the B+F since 2009.

[kruddler]

Apart from seasons ruined by injury, they've both consistently been top 5 in the B+F since 2009.

There's someone consistently in the top 5 B+F in the local underage club. Doesn't make them elite AFL players.
Someone will always finish top 5 in the B+F, they just haven't had a great load of competition.