RD 7 : Blues V Giants (Pre-Match Pre-Amble)

[Baggers]

Nah, someone had to give salary cap wise and he was it, he was deemed expendable so to speak. MM convinced him to come to Carlton, not to leave Sydney.

He's not hopeless by any means but he is a little soft.

So your argument is that because he was released by the Fluffy Ducks he's no good?  ???

[PassIt2Carrots]

So your argument is that because he was released by the Fluffy Ducks he's no good?  ???

No because he's been released by two clubs, which I clearly initially said, suggests that he's only average and it doesn't surprise me that he's not playing too well. His career has certainly not lived up to his first round pick status.

[MosquitoFleet]

70 point loss coming. ..

Cameron will kick 8....

[Diesel95]

we're tanking

[cookie2]

we're tanking

I think I may have posted this before, but if we are tanking then Mick is probably staying IMO.

[PassIt2Carrots]

Did anyone see the footage of Mick after our most recent loss? If we're tanking he has nothing to do with it.

[rocky]

I don't think we're tanking we're just kr@p.
On the Jones debate I agree he needs to be dropped, but to bring in a spud like Watson to replace him is a mistake. Please nobody give me the "he needs a chance" argument. He's had plenty. Just look at how he plays. He's lazy, unaccountable, bad skill set and relatively soft.
Wait a minute!
I stand corrected. He is an obvious choice for selection this week.

[crashlander]

Did anyone see the footage of Mick after our most recent loss? If we're tanking he has nothing to do with it.

Malthouse is trying hard. He is not tanking.
Are we tanking? Or are we as bad as it looks? We won't know the answer until we have something like a full list. If we come out to play.....

[ItsOurTime]

Jones needs to go back as he is making a mockery of this supposed culture building. If his name was j. Waite, Madhouse would have already organised the public stoning before this week's match.

[cookie2]

Malthouse is trying hard. He is not tanking.
Are we tanking? Or are we as bad as it looks? We won't know the answer until we have something like a full list. If we come out to play.....

If MM is not tanking then the club is not tanking. The players may just not be consciously or unconsciously trying or playing for the coach but I wouldn't call that tanking which is really trying consciously to improve your draft position.