Rd 13: Pre Game posturing: Carlton vs Gold Coast

[mateinone]

I think he went 53 because of exposed form. I think if he took the traditional route he would have gone higher.
You are of course entitled to a view, but I tend to think if he was freely available and not a Silvagni now, clubs would be keen to get hold of him.

Now I know Josh K was a different sort of player, when drafted he was 4 cm taller (now 5) and 4 kg heavier than Jack, but below are some comparisons of JK after 2 full seasons and Jack now after 1.5 seasons.

I am not drawing too much conclusion, other than to say his stats are decent for a 2nd year forward.



Anyway mate, each to their own and you are obviously more than entitled to have doubts on players (I have doubts on a few myself  ), I am sure we are both hoping in this instance you are wrong.