Jim Park Voting 2023 AFL Rd 10 Carlton vs Collingwood

[LP]

Team D

5 Doc
4 Charlie
3 Walsh
2 Cerra
1 Owies

[crashlander]

I'll probably close this thread tomorrow: I haven't voted yet.

[crashlander]

AFL Rd 10: Carlton vs Collingwood
Not good enough.
Rating: C-
I could have gone a lot lower, I might have had I voted on the day, I was so disappointed. But no matter how ordinary we were at times, we won the second half. Pity our disposal was so ordinary.

Votes:
[2.5] Marc Pittonet
[2.5] Adam Cerra
[2] Sam Docherty
[1.5] Sam Walsh
[1.5] Charlie Curnow
[1.5] Nic Newman
[1] Matthew Owies
[1] Matthew Kennedy
[0.5] Patrick Cripps
[0.5] Jordan Boyd
[0.5] Adam Saad

Explanations:
Nobody deserved more than 2 votes, which made things difficult.
[2.5] Marc Pittonet: Pitto was excellent in the ruck. Our one clear winner on the day.
[2.5] Adam Cerra: Probably our most effective midfielder, but that wasn’t good enough.
[2] Sam Docherty: Tried his guts out, but his disposal was terrible.
[1.5] Sam Walsh: Tried his guts out, but his disposal was faecal.
[1.5] Charlie Curnow: Could have won us the game if we could have got the ball to him. But we couldn’t and Charlie didn’t have his kicking boots on.
[1.5] Nic Newman: Our best defender. A winner.
[1] Matthew Owies: Didn’t get a lot of ball, but made each one count.
[1] Matthew Kennedy: Tried his guts out.
[0.5] Patrick Cripps: Tried hard, but his disposal was always under pressure.
[0.5] Jordan Boyd: Terrible early, but got right on to of his opponent.
[0.5] Adam Saad: Tried his guts out.

Honourable Mentions:
Lewis Young: Our best tall defender, his second half was pretty good.
Jack Silvagni: Tried hard in the ruck and wasn’t that bad.