Pre-Game Prattle: AFL Rd 10: Carlton vs St Kilda at Marvel

[WASurfer]

I'd rather leave Casboult in as backup ruckman rather than pull McKay away from the forward line as he's in great form down there. Charlie can have a run in the twos and give Kerr a chance...if Kerr's not up to it then he's another one to cull at year-end. But if we're picking players purely on form (as it should be) then Charlie isn't in the best 22 right at the minute.

[townsendcalling]

I think we should pick Kerr.
Casboult should have a spell, until his physicality is at AFL level

Generally speaking the squad is not reduced from the 18,  only those named on the interchange.

[JonHenry]

Generally speaking the squad is not reduced from the 18,  only those named on the interchange.

Yes unfortunately

[townsendcalling]

There is a definite 'need for speed' so, if fit, Cuningham is a cert, Kennedy is a lock, Stoker deserves another go and Plowman as the rotating backman.  Emergencies Fasolo, Kerr and Setterfield  Macreadie in the twos.

Pure speculation.

BINGO!!! Picked it!!  And Billy Longer didn't make the cut for the other mob.

[LP]

I didn't take Fasolo being named seriously, anyone who watched the VFL thought that must be a joke!

[WASurfer]

INS: Simpson, Kennedy, Plowman, Cunningham
OUTS: Setterfield, Murphy, O'Brien and Macreadie

The defence will look a bit better but hopefully Jones is back ASAP too. Cunningham adds a bit of speed and has been pretty sharp around the goals in the games he's played.

[LP]

INS: Simpson, Kennedy, Plowman, Cunningham
OUTS: Setterfield, Murphy, O'Brien and Macreadie

The defence will look a bit better but hopefully Jones is back ASAP too. Cunningham adds a bit of speed and has been pretty sharp around the goals in the games he's played.

Bit surprised we outed Setterfield, ahead of Ed or Gibbons. I apprecaite we cannot run with Cripps, Setterfield and Kennedy in the midfield but Setterfield is a useful forward.

Given SPS limited game time I won't be surprised to hear of a late change with SPS out and Setterfield in.

[laj]

Bit surprised we outed Setterfield, ahead of Ed or Gibbons. I apprecaite we cannot run with Cripps, Setterfield and Kennedy in the midfield but Setterfield is a useful forward.

Given SPS limited game time I won't be surprised to hear of a late change with SPS out and Setterfield in.

I'd have kept Setterfield ahead of Plowman.

[kruddler]

I reckon we'll respond, play a game similar to the one against the Dogs then turn around and an smack Essendon the week after because, well, it's something we enjoy doing. So i'm thinking we'll be 6 wins from 43...lol.

It already is 6 wins from 43.

THe magical numbers you throw around each week are chosen because the 2 weeks before that, were wins.....but that hurts the argument so they are conveniently left out.

If we do win the next 2, then it'd be 8 wins from 45.

[shawny]

All those saying setterfield should not be dropped did they miss the game last week.

The team was really bad but he was putrid.

Disposal is better in under 12s.

This guy has played a handful of poor - average games to start his career, However I’m not writing him off rather observing that his form has not been anywhere near enough to suggest he should have held his spot.

Hope he rips it up for a month in the 2s and can come back when he forces his way back....needs to work hard on disposal while in the seconds.