2019 - AFLW Votes - Winner - Bri Davey!

[Lods]

3 Davey
2 S. Hosking
1 Stevens

[DJC]

3 - Davey
2 - Downie
1 - Hosking, S

[kruddler]

Any other voters?

All the regulars have voted so far, but i expected a few part-timers to vote considering it was a Grand Final.

[kruddler]

GF: vs crows
3: Davey
2: S. Hosking
0.5: Stevens
0.5: Prespakis

Couldn't split the last 2 this week, which had a dramatic effect on the overall tallies.

For the first time all year, Prespakis is NOT leading the B+F count.

It all came down to the very last person putting in the very last votes.
Lods gave 1 vote to Stevens, and 0 to Prespakis, meaning they drew, meaning Prespakis fell 0.5 short.

So, Congrats to Bri Davey for winning the CSC B+F for 2019.

Final tally....
12: Davey
11.5: Prespakis
5.5: Harrington
5: Harris
4: Brazzale
3.5: Downie
3.5: Loynes
2.5: Pound
2.5: Walker
2: S. Hosking
1: Gee
0.5: Plane
0.5: Stevens

[kruddler]

OK, so last year i came up with an alternative leaderboard

This basically adds up what % of votes the girls get each week. So someone who ultimately gets BOG might not get BOG from every poster. So her score might be 2.63 votes for that round.

Alternatively, not every girl who gets a vote can make the 3, 2, 1 for that week. So someone might only get 1 vote total from all voters and would end up with something like 0.11 votes for that round.

Overall, i think this method rewards consistency and acknowledges those who do not get top 3 for any given week.

Anyway, every vote counted and allocated comes up with this alternative leaderboard.
1: Prespakis  (13.6)
2: Davey  (12.41)
3: Downie  (4.35)
4: Harrington  (3.96)
5: Harris  (3.55)
6: Loynes  (3.47)
7: Brazzale  (2.6)
8: Pound  (2.51)
9: Walker  (1.89)
10: S. Hosking  (1.72)
11: Gee  (1.03)
12: Stevens  (0.88)
13: Plane  (0.67)
14: Edwards  (0.5)
15: Mullane  (0.44)
16: Dalton  (0.22)
17: Van Dyke  (0.13)
18: J. Hosking  (0.11)

FWIW, Bri Davey got 4 BOGs for the year (hence 12 votes from the other leaderboard) but only votes in 2 of the other 5 games.
Maddie Prespakis received votes in every single game of the year, but was not BOG as much as Davey, only 3 times.

[kruddler]

For a bit of fun, i tallied up votes from the 5 voters who voted for every single game, including myself.

Here is their top 3.

kruddler
1st: Davey (12)
2nd: Prepsakis (11)
=3rd: Harris (6)
=3rd: Harrington (6)

Crashlander
1st: Davey (16)
2nd: Prespakis (15)
3rd: Pound (4)

riverrat
1st: Davey (14)
=2nd: Prespakis (9)
=2nd: Downie (9)

DJC
1st: Davey (14)
2nd: Prespakis (13)
3rd: Downie (5)

Navymaven
3: Prespakis (19)
2: Davey (9)
1: Harris (8)


So whichever way you slice it, Davey and Prespakis are 1 and 2 amongst CSC folk and after that its pretty even contribution.....but daylight to 3rd.

[DJC]

Thanks for your efforts Kruddler ... and the alternative analyses.

Do we communicate the results of our B&Fs to the club? 

[kruddler]

Thanks for your efforts Kruddler ... and the alternative analyses.

Do we communicate the results of our B&Fs to the club?

As with the mens, its always good to compare to the actual B+F results. See how astute our watchers are, and see what we might have missed.

[crashlander]

A great job of analysis, Kruddler.