2017 Jim Park Medal Analysis:

[flyboy77]

And yet Murphy regularly fails to influence the course of a game.....very sadly.

[dodge]

It's amazing the time and effort you're willing to put in when you enjoy doing something - well done, Crash, I enjoy your weekly summaries.

It is interesting that the top 5 have all bar one BOG for the season.  It is also interesting that two players that cause a bit of angst on this site - Murphy and Gibbs polled consistently well.  We must have got some recruiting right considering Murph, Kreuz and Gibbs were top draft picks and those who voted on this site had them all in our top 4.

Depending which side of the fence you sit on, you call this a success, or it points to the absolute failure if Murph and Gibbs are top 4.  Personally, I think it is a success and not their fault that they have been at the club that has been so poor at player development (IIRC Gibbs was put into the leadership in his debut season - crazy)

[flyboy77]

Yep, massive kudos to you Crashlander, a supreme effort~!

[madbluboy]

Be interesting how many BOGs we get on Brownlow night.

[Lods]

Be interesting how many BOGs we get on Brownlow night.

Not many!..."We're a 'champion team' (well...we're on the way to being one ) not a 'team of champions'..."

Our good performances this season have usually depended on all-round team performances and combination rather than depending on a Martin/Franklin performance by an individual.

But players like that are usually the difference between a 6 win year and a 15 win year....so we should probably get one....or make one out of material we already have (CC)  ;D

[maxm68]

Good work Crash

I voted 54321 on every game except r21 West Coast and r23 Sydney and came up with...

Murphy 43
Docherty 42
Kreuzer 36
Gibbs 30
Simmo and Cripps 26



I was pretty close to what the club came up with

[DJC]

Good work Crash

I voted 54321 on every game except r21 West Coast and r23 Sydney and came up with...

Murphy 43
Docherty 42
Kreuzer 36
Gibbs 30
Simmo and Cripps 26

Nice work; you're on the same page as our coaches!  You may wish to keep it quiet though; the anti-Murphy, anti-Gibbs brigade will be accusing you of everything from improper dealings to bias 



I was pretty close to what the club came up with