Round 20: Carlton vs Brisbane Post Game Pain

[RiverRat]

And seriously, WTF is David Ellard getting a full game ahead of Holman? I mean seriously WTF. Is this club fair dinkum? You have a bloke about to get delisted, getting a full game ahead of another who perhaps has a future and needs to get games into himself. WTF is this idiot club doing?

Barker has well and truly lost me and if Abdy McKay has anything to do with that then he needs to go as well.

At least they are not dumb enough to pick Watson.

[RiverRat]

Fwiw, id prefer Dew as coach over Bolton. I just dont see enough C**t in Bolton to be a senior coach.

If he has any, it would fade into insignificance next to Clarkson - hard to tell until the brighter light goes behind a cloud.

[RiverRat]

Jamison should retire like 10 others and don't hit our salary cap. ...do the honorable thing....

Jamo is far from the player he was but he is still our best tall defender

[MilkIt]

I agree, Scache is the man.

Crash, if you're reading, does Scache come with leadership qualities?

I want Weitering. Schache is a bit of a one trick pony IMO. Given we have Casboult who is a similar type I would be going with the key defender because Jamison is cooked and Rowe is just not very good. From what I've heard, Weitering is a better athlete and has better leadership qualities.

Weitering also beat him one on one.

[thrunthrublu]

schache thanks.
Beautiful left foot kick, good overhead.
will be a real machine once he's had a preseason with dank

[cimm1979]

;D

You guys haven't even seen him play. ;D

C'mon. How would we know?

Reading Cazzeman, he reckons it's Weitering by some margin.

Like I said once before, we should just ask Hughes who he'd take, and then take the other one, or pick 7.

[PassIt2Carrots]

Have seen some of Scache. Not prepared to write him off especially for the better athlete. I like your Hughes theory though.

@RiverRat

Cmon mate it's becoming a hit of an obsession of yours isn't it? No one is allowed to comment on Watson?

[PassIt2Carrots]

I just had flashbacks to hotcox and Edwards

Mate you have got so much wrong over time that I've let slide it's just not funny. In fact you have gotten pretty much everything wrong:

- you'll know we have i proved when Carrazzo and Sctoland can't get a game (my all time fav)

- let's take Leuenberger or Hansen over Gibbs

- Mick has improved this side (another ripper)

- getting rid of Robbo is great for culture

- let's not sack Mick

That's just off the top of my head. If you want to go on about hotcox style comments and getting it wrong all the time look no further than yourself.

[Thryleon]

;D

You guys haven't even seen him play. ;D

C'mon. How would we know?

Reading Cazzeman, he reckons it's Weitering by some margin.

Like I said once before, we should just ask Hughes who he'd take, and then take the other one, or pick 7.

ROFL!

[ElwoodBlues1]

Weitering for me.....beat Schache  during the carnival and has already been tested vs mature players.....had leadership qualities and is a more polished player IMO....if Cazzeman reckons Weitering is better then thats who we will be taking given his connections to the recruiting dept.

I understand the love for Schache given his size, kicking and domination at U 18 level but I think he will come back to the field vs mature age players, I also understand we have been burned by the recruiting of Watson and another so called ready to go CHB has people thinking twice...