2015-Rnd 3 Carlton vs Essendon

[LP]

Casboult when that loose ess player blocks your hole u know wat to do

Casboult isn't like that, but Watson will be if they get him right!

[laj]

I said that we couldn't beat top 4 sides when we peaked under Ratten and 2011 was his peak.
We won one final in his 5 and a bit years and the team who "robbed" us of a prelim had been wooden spooners a few years prior,  they got smashed in the prelim like we would have.
We need a complete overhaul,  with or without Malthouse.

I'd have taken copping a kicking in a PF..lol.

Actually, we were very competitve against top sides that year without winning. Would've ahve won but mightn't have copped the same flogging as the Eagles.

[kruddler]

I'd have taken copping a kicking in a PF..lol.

Actually, we were very competitve against top sides that year without winning. Would've ahve won but mightn't have copped the same flogging as the Eagles.

We were very competitve against top sides last year without winning.
Geelong twice (5 points and 6 points).
Freo once. (6 points)
Hawks once (28 points in the end - but 4 points early in the last quarter).

[Thryleon]

Bringing in 15 plodders that were delisted from other clubs was not a rebuild.

Thry your hypotheticals are just that, hypotheticals. Anyone can try and deflect from the truth by raising hypothetical theories.

Thats the Carlton rebuild that got us to 5th Carrots.  You know, the one where we started recruiting guys like Carrazzo and Simpson.

Decided to rebuild around Fevola, and our number 1 draft picks.

You should know this, you are a Carlton supporter are you not?

[shadesy]

Graham, Boekhorst, Walker, Cripps and Buckley as minimum inclusions. Big game at the G, lets see what you can do (Walker aside).

I would bring in Watson for Jones, but wont happen.

Holman to get a taste maybe. I am really hoping Walsh can provide some grunt and leadership soon.

Outs: White, Curnow, Tutt, Ellard... One from Bell, Carrazzo, Smith

[MosquitoFleet]

Graham, Boekhorst, Walker, Cripps and Buckley as minimum inclusions. Big game at the G, lets see what you can do (Walker aside).

I would bring in Watson for Jones, but wont happen.

Holman to get a taste maybe. I am really hoping Walsh can provide some grunt and leadership soon.

Outs: White, Curnow, Tutt, Ellard... One from Bell, Carrazzo, Smith

nahh

make a statement  outs one of gibbs or murphy  ....and carrozzo

[cookie2]

nahh

make a statement  outs one of gibbs or murphy  ....and carrozzo

I'd be giving strong consideration to "giving Murph a rest "due to a knee concern" and making Simmo captain for this one. We need to try and shake things up a bit, break the evil spell. Hopefully Cripps and Walker both will be available.

[Juddkreuzer]

I'd be giving strong consideration to "giving Murph a rest "due to a knee concern" and making Simmo captain for this one. We need to try and shake things up a bit, break the evil spell. Hopefully Cripps and Walker both will be available.

Murph says he's fine.

[cookie2]

Murph says he's fine.

Think of another reason then, but I'd still be considering that option. 

[MosquitoFleet]

Think of another reason then, but I'd still be considering that option. 

AGREE...the MC decides not the player