Should we chase Josh Schache?

[LP]

Holman is 189cm and 87kg , apart from Cripps he is bigger than any of our other mids, agree he isnt quick but he is a rugged strong unit now and a real tackling machine...for nothing on the rookie list I reckon he could be value....

But I think that was his problem, when he came in he had the reputation but didn't deliver on it, I think it was because of his lack of pace at AFL level. He was just out of too many contests.

If you could carry just one slowish inside midfielder assuming Kreuzer keeps his main rucking role, who would you choose Cripps or Holman? Obviously Cripps.

Now that C.Curnow is at the club, who gives Cripps a midfield chop out, C.Curnow or Holman, Charlie gets the nod for me.

I too liked Holman, but I just can't see him displacing the guys we have as first choice options. If we had to fill some spots on the list I'd like to see a few really hard at it fast breakaway types.

Look at how our team full of kids nearly de-constructed Norps game plan at the weekend, do they have too many Holman types in their rotation?