Worst Leaders in the AFL!

[PaulP]

I will stick my neck out...

Taking judd has prevented the development of leaders just like gazza at gold coast

Murph gibbs are too soft now and fall into bad habits when the heat is on.
.

If what you postulate is true, then both Murph and Gibbs have questionable characters to begin with, and are probably not leadership material, irrespective of whether Judd came to the club or not. 

The footage in the WCE game during one of the breaks, showing Judd giving the troops a rev up rather than Murph, is worrying. Yes, it's only a tiny snippet, and I don't know what happens in the thousands of hours we don't see, but it's a disturbing snippet.