Jim Park Voting; Round 1: Carlton vs Richmond

[Baggers]

Not far below my B- maximum. When you're a poor team though playing a finals team some losses are "more acceptable" than others, without at all being accepted as that will turn you into a $hit team quick smart. If we lost to Hawthorn by a point I could push to a B. If we lost to Essendon by a point we'd get a Z. Hence I use the word "context" before as not one size fits all. A 20 goal grand final win? Think I would just lose the whole load...lol.

Well said. Likewise, B- is my maximum losing grading.

But maybe, like others have suggested, this particular topic should be for ratings etc only and not questioning the validity of another's rationale. Just thoughts...