(03-21-2016, 10:05 AM)DJC link Wrote:Give it up LP! When have I ever belittled Andy McKay?
Everyone with a skerrick of knowledge of how Carlton was operating knows that Malthouse and Swann sidelined McKay to give Daisy the deal to secure his financial future.
Your spurious argument collapses because vets, despite their extensive training, do not study human anatomy and physiology. Furthermore, our club should be condemned if they relied on a vet to determine whether a crippled player could be rehabilitated. That has to be up there with some of the most stupid comments ever posted here. You've really excelled this time: congratulations!
Nobody has made any assumptions about McKay diagnosing Daisy, you are just trying to infer that to colour the debate.
But even after his most basic training McKay is infinitely more qualified than any coach, trainer, recruiter, administrator or taxonomist to listen to the assessment of the experts, form an opinion, make a decision and communicate that to the club.
You are happy to condemn his involvement in the process, yet next to the clubs orthopedic surgeons he was probably equal to or better than any other person in the club to be involved. It's just bizarre you continue your attack, you must really hate McKay!
Your closed minded attitude is the old Carlton, the bad Carlton, the thing that holds us back! Look for some positives in life, I appreciate it must be hard to do when your stuck dealing with the dead all day, but make an effort it will be rewarding!
"Ruck, ruck, ruck, ruck ....... Ruck, ruck, ruck, ruck"