AFL Finals 2024 Carlton vs Brisbane in Brisbane

[kruddler]

Only that haters gonna hate. There's no point looking for rational reasons, there are none. He's just this year's whipping boy, like many others before him.

Your defending of him is not rational either......but its your point of view so anything to the contrary MUST be irrational.

What is it that he offers us?
What does he do that the alternatives do not?
As a mature age player, is he worth persisting with over a younger alternative who MAY be slightly down on output by comparison.
Think TDK vs Pitto. People wanted TDK playing because of potential and needing game time.....and Pitto to make way for that.
There is nothing wrong with that logic, and example.
But it seems the when the shoe is on the other foot, peoples opinions on what is actually important seem to change as well.