The Great Ruck Debate.

[LP]

The people against the '1 ruck' team lineup do so because they are worried about injuries, specifically an injury to that ruck.
This is where luck comes into it.

You're misleading the debate and verballing other forums members;

If we list the issues that have been discussed at length in this thread and others;
- Injury to a solo ruck issue is one.
- Offering KPP backup / flexibility.
- Surrendering momentum to strong opposition rucks.
- Season long viability. (That one is mental and physical)
- Overloading already heavily loaded players like Cripps or Harry. (Risk of injury and freshness.)
- Wasting valuable premium AFL resources (Like wedging a Coleman or Brownlow Medallist into a B-Grade ruck role.)
- Flexible team tactics.