AFL Rd 17 2024 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs GWS

[kruddler]

So ignoring all your usual slights, you're going to assert sending TDK back out there on a jabbed up ankle he can barely stand on, barely mobile and unable to jump, is a valid test of his KPD capability.

That's as bad if not worse than claiming TDK against a "no ruck Handbagger squad" is proof solo rucks work, not that anybody would be brazen enough to make that claim!

Even with [member=105]Thryleon[/member] and myself posting the same basic response, the obvious response, you failed to answer either with anything more than smoke and mirrors, as usual!

So TDK couldn't play back because he was sore.
So you are holding out hope for Pittonet to stop Hogan?
TDK isn't a defender.
Pittonet isn't a defender.
No amount of planning could have stopped the onslaught that occured when we lost Weitering.

.....except if we had maybe chosen some more KPD's at the draft table over the past i dunno, 7 years! Who thought of that??

Oh 1 ruck vs cats is not valid because cats were crap. (Keep in mind my comments are for our team, not anybody elses)
0 rucks vs freo last year is also not valid because.....it hurts people arguments too much?

BTW, how many key defenders do we have in the side? Some people say 3. You say you need more.

Funny, i don't recall all of these 'obvious' calls coming in the lead up to the match. Only during.

Maybe offer some pearls of wisdom before this happens rather than halfway through the game if they are so obvious in the future.
Weren't very obvious is the first quarter were they.