06-30-2024, 11:52 PM
(06-30-2024, 11:38 PM)PaulP link Wrote:Top 5 is too few IMO. No matter which 5 you nominate, others who are equally valuable miss out. Also worth noting that whatever top 5 one nominates look as good as they do because the support crew around them is now up to snuff. If you pick Cripps, Weitering, Fogarty, either one of Curnow / McKay, and De Koning, that still omits Walsh, Cincotta, Newman etc. I think it's great that we have this problem. Way more than 5 "most valuable' IMO.
It's the diversity of the opinion I'm looking for without going to deep in the list....
You won't see a lot of difference with the top 2 or 3, but around 4 and 5 you may get some different names.
My top 2 in order were easy...
It's
1) Weitering
2) Cripps.
(remembering it's not the best, but most valuable)
After that I struggle a bit
I'd probably have one of the key forwards...and I'd probably go for McKay over Curnow at this stage.
Where to next I'm not sure.
Walsh, Curnow, DeKoning (we've won well without them, or without them having a lot of influence) or one of the role players that provide us with a much needed aspect we get from no other player.