AFL Rd 6 2024 Pre Game Prognostications Carlton vs GWS

[pinot]

First of all, VFL form doesn't mean AFL form.
Plenty of great VFL players haven't made it at AFL level.

Secondly, where do you want us to play Binns?
Acres, Hollands (x2), Cottrell all play similar position and all are doing well enough in those positions so far.
So we drop a regular AFL player for a rookie because......why?

I've got nothing against Binns. Honestly, i couldn't pick him out of a crowd, i just don't understand why we are pushing for a bloke when he doesn't fill a position we need filling.
Its like if a ruck was the most in form player in the VFL and dominating all comers. Do we introduce him to the 1's when we have TDK (and now Pittonet) playing decent enough footy? No, there isn't a spot, no matter how well he might be playing.

Ollie Hollands needs a spell imo.