AFL 2023 Preliminary Final Carlton vs Brisbane Post Game Prognostications

[kruddler]

Nothing like flogging a dead horse ?

Just pointing out that you agree with me without realising it.

I think that most folk agree that playing Jack Silvagni as second ruck does not work.  He might get the odd clearance but the opposition second stringers touch him up.  McInerney and Daniher would have a picnic, as would Cox and Cameron.

Backing up in the ruck also affects Jack’s output as third tall forward.

Our best ruck combination, until someone else comes along, is Pittonet and De Koning, followed by De Koning and O’Keeffe, then Pittonet and O’Keeffe.

The solution to the lack of foot speed by some of our mids isn’t playing the even slower Silvagni as a second ruck.

Anyway, we won 11 of our last 13, the only team to do so, and I think the MC have got the team balance exactly where it should be.

Your comments about us 'suffering' in the ruck by comparison and Jacks output as a forward have both been debunked with stats, but you continue to push it. So be it. I don't expect to change your mind.

I will point out when you agree with the logic behind it.
I will point out when any objections are untrue.