(07-16-2023, 05:44 AM)shawny date Wrote:I don’t disagree with any of that. My point is there is no comparison between Pitt and TDK.Not sure what fans have against TDK, some hate that he's attracting big coin, others hate that he is often competing with a Silvagni for a spot in the match day squad.
What TDK is worth is another discussion but I do understand why TDK is getting the big offers while Pitt committed to 4 years on average coin. It’s pretty obvious imo.
I think it's unfair to compare Pitto and TDK, very very different players, Pitto is more like Lycett last night, TDK is more Gawn / Jackson like. I don't understand how fans don't see the difference and how they compliment each other, and of course there will be games when we should only play one or the other with a SoJ or Young backup.
On the stats, there are empty stats and then there are quality stats, I don't care how some want to negatively spin his stats TDK was in quality overload last night!
Only having Pitto makes us much too easy to plan against in my opinion, it pigeon holes our team tactically, a lot the fan debate argues like there is a definitive right or wrong way when it's nothing of the sort, it's horses for courses. Make the wrong choice on biggest day of the year and a squad that has the either / or like Melbourne or even more options like Geelong can ruin your day!
"Ruck, ruck, ruck, ruck ....... Ruck, ruck, ruck, ruck"