(07-06-2023, 01:39 AM)kruddler date Wrote:So if TDK cannot perform to Pittonets standard in the ruckYou keep making he same mistake, it's your narrow definition of performing in the ruck that is your folly, when you make those mistakes it exposes your perceptions which appear to contradict what you write. In philosophy they would assert you lack referentially integrity.
and
Cannot perform to Jacks standard around the ground.....and arguably does not outperform Jack in the ruck either.
Then why are we playing him? Because we HOPE he gets better??
As for TDK's best games, they already match SoJ, but TDK is not yet consistent, given a similar number of games TDK is already on a trajectory that puts him way beyond the capabilities of SoJ, there is no comparison long term.
We've just signed Pitto for four years, he's the foundation, TDK or another ultra mobile ruck like him is the complimentary machinery that sits on it, SoJ or Young are not!
There is another very simple question that can be posed to determine if we have a null hypothesis, head to head in a combative scenario, if we become like the Romans and set the three of them a fight to the death, survival of the fittest, last man of earth, overhead, in mobility, pace, agility, potential and ruck work, do Young and SoJ have TDK covered?
"Ruck, ruck, ruck, ruck ....... Ruck, ruck, ruck, ruck"

