The rise.... and RISE of Marc Pittonet

[kruddler]

Fans fear for SoJ so they are creating scenarios to try and give him a way forward, in actual fact that's destroying the blokes career because it's plain as day he's failing at it, he is never going to be a bull like Pitto and he is not athletic like TDK.

I think SoJ would be fine if people stopped talking him up as a ruck option and we just let him play the roles he is suited to play.

Is it at all possible for you to debate the 2nd ruck scenario WITHOUT going into SOS conspiracy theories?

You've tried twisting the debate in all sorts of directions in terms of TDK vs SOS, but the only reason SOS was even in the debate is because that was who was playing at the time.
The same debate can be had with TDK for Young, McKay, Cripps....whoever.

Take home point is TDK is not delivering and cannot legitimately hold down any other position on the ground. As a result its in our best interests to play someone who can. Up to this point, its largely been SOS. At one point, it was Young. We've used Harry when deep forward and even Cripps has contested a few as well. Its not a matter of WHO plays the 2nd ruck position as long as its not 2 dedicated rucks, it doesn't help the team.