(05-23-2023, 03:19 AM)BluePhantom date Wrote:Because everything else is working really well at the moment too?No matter, he won't be winning everything one on one next to Charlie and trailing Franklin around at the other end at the same time.
Inventing a role for Liam Jones in the backline was a bridge to far as well?
McKay is probably our best defensive forward. Has great closing speed and tackles well. Get his mind off the stress of kicking goals to win games (even though that is his job)
Doing the same thing over and over again expecting different results...... :o
McKay and Charlie are both Coleman medallists, so it makes a lot of sense to turn either of them into B-Grade defenders, apparently Carlton is the only team in the AFL where fans think being a Coleman medallist isn't good enough to cut it as a forward!
Just leave the B-Grade Defenders we've already got in place, because moving Young up the other end won't help our forwards to get closer to the sprayed delivery. No matter how poor some might think McGovern(aka The new Plowman) or Young have been, I'm betting they are an arm and a leg ahead of two newbies like SoJ or McKay as one on one defenders.
"Ruck, ruck, ruck, ruck ....... Ruck, ruck, ruck, ruck"