AFL Rd 1 2023 Pre Game Prognostications Carlton vs Richmond

[LP]

No I am not saying Cripps and Walshes B&Fs were bogus. Yes I am questioning the previous coaches' quality wrt rating
and giving Plowman votes.

So under what mechanism do they become reliable assessor of some player and wildly inaccurate for another?

I'll presume the only answer you can offer is "When they pick him!" ;D

It'll be interesting to see which player cops the stay at home role tonight, and how long it takes for fans to sledge them?

It's probably 50/50 to be Cowan or Newman, at which time we go Edgar Allen Poe on them, "tch tch, ........... nevermore!" :o