08-16-2021, 02:43 AM
(08-16-2021, 02:28 AM)Thryleon link Wrote:Thats fine, but had Collingwood been Carlton, we probably would have sacked him circa 2004, and then not won the flag in 2010.
He definately wouldnt have lasted 2005 on the back of 2004. THAT is the difference between us and Collingwood. We might have even sacked him after the second successive Grand Final loss to Brisbane.
We would have said after being in 3 grand finals, Mick isnt good enough to win won, and sacked him.
Yeah to be clear I'm definitely not disagreeing with you. Our club finds ways to shoot its own foot off. Just pointing out where Clarkson is at now is more akin to when MM joined Collingwood as opposed to when he joined us which - I agree - was when he was past it and also after a full year out.

