Pre game postulations: AFL 2021 Rd 5: Carlton vs Port Adelaide at the MCG

[Baggers]

I don't know about "unlucky to be dropped", the coaches have seen something that has caused concerns, many here and other sites have also been vocal about Setter's form in all the games this year. To me, Dow at least looks like he is having a crack or displays some urgency, I can't say the same for young Wil. Interesting how we see things differently though. What's important now is that the 22 that run out tonight get the job done.

Yep.

Perhaps we've become so accustomed to being where we are on the ladder that we're grateful for anything that looks like being okay or showing promise, and hence make excuses or look for any positives.

Yes, Dow looks like he's having a red hot dip, so we cut him slack... but at what cost to our potential success? Ultimately, he is not delivering and seems to have lost confidence - a few dominant games in the Magoos might be just what he needs.

Setters is almost the opposite. His vision and disposal by hand, especially, is really good and has resulted in many good links... but, that's it! Too one-dimensional. And really doesn't seem to want to impose himself on the contest with any physicality and that hurts our defensive efforts in particular.

So, IMHO, both Dow and Setters are very limited in what they can offer, at present. Both have much to learn... but will they? Maybe they're both just not quite AFL standard? Time will tell.

I hope this is a pattern for our selection committee... more ruthlessness - not delivering on expectations? Out you go. Harsh but needed if we are to become a finalist.