Community Cup Carlton vs St. Kilda

[keogh]

Zac has been excellent, Saad not so good IMO.

Big tick to the recruiters.

Williams and Saad CLEARLY improve our side.

1.5 million and a pick 8 so they should
Saad leaked goals in first half
Is purely a player in the easiest position on the ground
Williams is a very good player but he did nothing in the last
We are asking a player to become a mid week in week out after he has played virtually all his career in defense
So he should on $850000 a year for 5 years
Martin by the way is so overrated
What has he achieved in his career so far
Poor recruiting over the last 5 years
I look at the list overall and there are too many average players
IMO we overate our list  we have for the last 20
Years
5 spoons
13 bottom 6 finishes
4 final appearances one a token
No preliminary final experience
There is your proof we overate our list
We lack pace so we recruit 3 establish players  who are quick give up picks and salary cap space and the presumption is we will be ok
We won’t progress unless SPS Dow OBrien etc get better