Round 20: Carlton vs Brisbane Post Game Pain

[Lods]

No doubt Menzel was given a wake up call by being dropped after lack of effort/poor form in recent weeks but like a good player he repsonded and was easily in our best players for
the NB;s last week and should have been a monty to get picked if we were serious about winning....picking Dick and Ellard over Menzel tells me we were never serious about winning this game....
I'd be expecting Jones and Tutt back for next week just to make sure of the result...

I just don't see the logic though....
Had Menzel played it would have made little difference to the result.
Yarran could have played at his best and it would have made little difference to the result.
Even if we are tanking we don't need to have them playing VFL.