08-14-2020, 08:44 AM
(08-14-2020, 08:27 AM)kruddler link Wrote:Well you tell me. You said Murphy is keeping someone out of the side. Who?Its not about this season, we wont be playing finals IMO and I would have played Dow, Philp, Obrien ahead of Murphy and if Stocker was fit/available ahead of Simpson....
Who will be better in the 22 than Murphy?
As for our depth....
McKay
Curnow
McGovern
J. Silvagni
Kreuzer
N. Newman
Cuningham
All unavailable for selection last match. All would be picked by most to be in our best 22.
On top of that, fringe players like Marchbank and Dow are coming back from injury and have not been deemed match fit yet. Neither has Kemp who we recruited injured.
Along with the 22 that played last week. That is 32 players from our list. There is only a 46 players on our list, so how many of the 14 players not in either list are good enough to keep Murphy out of the side?
We've given at least 1 game to
Moore
Lang
Philp
None of them are the answer.
Honey gets a game this week.
Who is left?
Macreadie
Polson
Stocker
Obrien
Owies
Goddard
Ramsay
Phillips
Odwyer
B. Silvagni
Which of those 10 offers the side more than Murphy?
Name any of them....i dare ya.
This is the season where you can experiment and not kill the coach, next season is when we want our best team on the park each week.