Pre game postulations: AFL 2020 Rd 5: Carlton vs St. Kilda

[Baggers]

I reckon Philp should have been given another game purely on the basis of that sublime pick up under pressure in the last quarter.

One game and out is not a good way to introduce a young bloke to the pressures of AFL and it could make him even more nervous when he gets his next chance. 

Fish needs more than a cameo ten possessions to justify Philp's omission.

Well said.

In his (Philp) after game interview it sounded as if he already knew that this year might hold such decisions. Personally, I believe his leg speed would have been really useful against the Aints.

And I completely agree with other comments here re: Fisher and Setterfield. And Plowman's form worries me somewhat as well. There'd want to be some good stuff from Fisher, Setterfield, Plowman and Newnes for mine. And time for H to do more as well. Might sound a little too critical but if we're to start winning games by deserved margins then we cannot have passengers.