06-14-2020, 02:41 AM
(06-14-2020, 02:08 AM)flyboy77 link Wrote:Rubbish.
Walsh was poor yesterday. Had multiple chances to deliver passes I50 at critical stages and butchered them all. He wasn't alone!
Ed was ok, Muphy bruise free....
Setters chose to leave GWS - should be cherry ripe this year but....needs to be played somewhere where he can find some form (2s ideally in a normal world).
Lang chose to walk - was one of the Cats best in at least 1 of the finals he played before leaving. But shouldn't be picked again unless we have major injuries...would prefer Owies getting a game.
Newnes - was offered a deal at Saints but clearly had had a falling out with the hierarchy there - was never going to be an A grader there or here. In any event, not the reason we lost yesterday but he now has the same malaise that most of our team has....Ikonitis?
SPS - not tough enough? BS. Throw him into the middle, leave him there....
We have the capacity (or did) to pay for another A grader. A Wines or Crouch or the ilk far more important to us than a Tom Papley type....
Need both Wines and B. Crouch IMO......
SPS has the talent but doesnt do enough and when the game is a bit scrappy vs more average players he seems to sit back a bit IMO, the better the opposition the better he plays IMO. Would expect him to do much better vs Geelong this week.
We are a soft midfield IMO and need some bigger bodies like Wines to take the heat off Cripps
E. Curnow and Murphy are going to be calls we need to make at seasons end...dont think we can go with both...
Cripps, Walsh, Wines and B. Crouch...with M. Crouch a year later is more my type of midfield if you want to go places....