Carlton vs Brisbane Practice Match

[PaulP]

Malthouse may have been a good coach, but he was cooked and only took the job with us to give the finger to Eddie.  Started off by disenfranchising the players.  For a supposed supercoach that's straight out stupid.  I'm not saying the list was good,  but if you lose them before you start they are never going to perform

I respectfully disagree. He was and is a good coach IMO. I find it rather amusing that only our players crack the sads - the Pies players, Eagles etc. all happy to play under him, but not us.

I've not met one single person who thinks his career or reputation is any way diminished as a result of his time at Carlton. Not one.

He's grumpy, curmudgeonly and combative, and given his record with us, is therefore easy to dislike. Not surprising that becomes an easy target for disillusioned, pitchfork wielding Blues supporters, looking for someone to blame, and yet again, not seeing the forest for the trees.