03-05-2019, 06:31 AM
(03-05-2019, 02:09 AM)LP link Wrote:I'm a bit skeptical of the stats Kruddler. One of the reasons I gave Van Dyke votes was I thought she never once wasted he football, and the stats support that with 100% efficiency. I thought Davey won a lot of football but wasted a bit of it, yet the official stats have her also at 95%.
I thought Van Dyke, Harrington and Hosking were the three that stood firm when the Filth got on a roll which is why I gave them the votes. I might have also gave Pound a vote but she did have a couple of significant clangers.
I wasn't going to comment on your votes, but since you brought it up.....Hosking? I'd combine the efforts of both of them and couldn't fit them in the votes.
Van Dyke....she;d maybe be the 4th best defender on the night...maybe. Well by the votes, she is the 4th best defender Harrington+Pound+Stevens, all have more votes. Probably couldn't tell you a 5th defender TBH.
re Davey, wasn't her best ever game, but thats the point of my comments re her stats. It was a decent, not outstanding, game and she dominated the stats.
Yes stats are not the be-all and end-all, but given the amount of votes our defenders have got this year, it appears people are well aware of that.