Hannah Mouncey

[Thryleon]

But is her size the critical issue, or the fact that she used to be a male ? If it's the former, what about Shane Mumford v Marc Murphy ? You can't discriminate in the men's game because someone is too big, or too strong. The fact that Daisy Pearce may be a typical size female AFL footballer and Murphy an atypically small male player is not the issue IMO.

The critical issue is I am an average male, and Hannah is an above average sized former male now wanting to play against females.

The muddying of this issue of Marc Murphy vs shame Mumford is ridiculous.

Murphy's small by afl sizes but not abnormally so.  There's plenty of shorter players as well as Murphy sized ones.  Likewise Mumford is large but not abnormally so and he is not a rarity either.

Hannah Mouncey is abnormally large for a female, and is going to have a strength advantage that mkst females, not even the abnormal ones, simply won't ever have over their counterparts.