05-11-2018, 09:04 AM
(05-11-2018, 08:04 AM)PaulP link Wrote:I'm not really sure how you can quote Daisy Thomas (who as far as I can tell is a player, not a supporter) and from that conclude that some supporters may think CC is laissez faire, and therefore not like it ?
The Swans supporter base voted for Roos out of love and loyalty, not football knowledge. Some coaches make it work at one club and not others. Wallace may have netted the Swans 2 or 3 flags, or 2 or 3 spoons. We will never know. The point is that the clubs spend a lot more time and effort in making these decisions, and make them with access to a wealth of knowledge that supporters can only dream of. Us humans are unpredictable buggers. Trying to select the right human for a particular task will never have a 100% success rate. But the right systems, methods and processes are critical. Otherwise we end up with the club equivalent of the car Homer Simpson designed.
So we can't use Daisy Thomas' evaluation of a player because he isn't a supporter.
Yet, you go on to say that the club knows best.
No comment about the salary cap breaches i threw in there?
Pretty sure supporters would know its not the right way to run a club.
