05-02-2018, 03:03 AM
(05-02-2018, 02:02 AM)LP link Wrote:You want it to be, but the only non-subjective measure we have is when they played in the same games with or against each other. Everything else you write is opinion!
It's the accepted way to measure sporting talent, the very same way many sports establish the best of the best, by examining their results either side by side or head to head.
If I looked at Jacobs versus all teams, Carlton is middle of the field.
Sam Jacobs Against Opposition Teams
Hardly dominant!
You seem to be forgetting the stats i wrote were exactly that!
If you don't trust the stats, see who has more brownlow votes in head to head. Sauce 2-0.
I don't care who is the better ruckman against other teams. Its not about that! Its about head to head and their matchup this week. Nothing else matters. We can have the same discussion every week with Kreuzer vs ***** and it will be different.
You keep trying totwist the argument into something it is not as deflection.