(05-02-2018, 12:09 AM)kruddler link Wrote:That is 100% subjective and even the 'stats' you indirectly talk about doesn't actually back up your argument.
That is like saying Tony Locketts best game of AFL football were not against Carlton when he was at St. Kilda. And Luke O'Sullivans best games were against St. Kilda....so Rhino is better than Plugger. That logic makes no correlation to their base performances. Loosely summarised, Plugger averaged 5 goals a game. Rhino, 5 games a year.
There is simply so much wrong with what you right, that i'm simply going to agree to disagree.
Ignoring the Freudian slip, you are not getting out of this by reverting to your usual absurdities, you have made a rubbish statement.
Here is a Final Siren Head to Head, the relevant section shows reality about any claims of Jacobs domination against Carlton.
I suspect like many fans, your rage at losing Jacobs has coloured your perception of his performances!
"Ruck, ruck, ruck, ruck ....... Ruck, ruck, ruck, ruck"