04-05-2018, 04:57 AM
(04-05-2018, 02:01 AM)LP link Wrote:Deags, Thry and Sandsmere are correct.
You basically assert that the VFL not having started is no basis for form good or bad, practice match or not, then assert that a kid who has shown nothing in meaningless VFL practice games deserves a run!
If you want to make your point you have to compare Daniher's VFL career pre-AFL selection, to McKay's VFL form, which is of course impossible because McKay's form line is virtually non-existent.
The only real indicator of any value we have is the VFL coaches feedback, and at the moment the McKay stuff isn't grabbing anyone's attention. Up until now, McKay's all reputation and potential with little performance.
Not what I am asserting at all.
I am asserting that McKay's is no worse than Kerr's form and that if we really want him to develop as A KEY FORWARD (or even THE key forward), we might as well have him playing in the 1s....
That said, if his attitude is all wrong - and on that I have no idea, of course he shouldn't be promoted.
Finals, then 4 in a row!