04-04-2018, 08:47 AM
(04-04-2018, 07:01 AM)Shakin77 link Wrote:I get that it didnt work but the other options where piss poor. M Its not like we passed over Shane Mumford or Justin Madden who where running around in the twos.
McKay would have added zero in the ruck. 5 hit outs max. Maybe a goal or two up forward but with the delivery from the midfield more likley zero
No one in that VFL side would have made any difference.
This game wasnt lost at the selection table
And for the record a three tall forward line? Yeah that would help our crowded and congested forward line. A defenders dream
If Kreuzer was there though Casboult would've been forward. All it would've been as talls nwas McKay and Curnow rather than Casboult and Curnow. It would've had the effect of splitting their defence a bit more. McKay would've added value around the ground too when he was on the ball.
In the end though, our attitude and workrate was so poor that it wouldn't have mattered who we picked.