03-23-2018, 07:22 AM
(03-23-2018, 07:16 AM)LP link Wrote:The trouble is Kruddler, I don't want to see it but Weitering is probably also a better forward than SoJ. I think that was the mistake our club made, and it will take sometime to correct.
I have no problems with SoJ or with his work ethic, but through the JLT and after last night it's clear he doesn't deserve a spot any more than some of the alternatives. I'd have even played O'Shea as a HFF ahead of him. People forget O'Shea has played 81 games for Port, he's no newbie, his best game came as a HBF pushing forward against GWS!
...and if they want to pick Weitering as a forward and drop Casboult, i'd support that.
I'd prefer they play McKay there first as Weitering is more of a known by comparison. But long term if McKay doesn't cut it and Weitering does, more power to him.
As for Oshea, got nothing against him, but i wouldn't have picked him up. Again, list management...too many backmen. I know SOS was a backman and has a good eye for them, but he needs to remember you can only play 6 of them at once. Sad thing is, SOS has kicked more goals than anyone on our list.