JLT 2018: Carlton vs St Kilda at Ikon on Wednesday

[kruddler]

Your logic is flawed, Weitering is the same age and requires games every bit as much as Harry does. The fact he is further  in front (and by a fair way) suggests that you need to keep playing him or he risks falling back.

Why is it flawed? Because i prefer Harry to play forward?

I've already suggested that if the club wanted to play Weitering forward instead of Casboult, i'd be more in favour of it than if it was instead of McKay.

So because Weitering (20) is young he gets games and pushes another player out of the side who might be a couple years older like Marchbank (21), Plowman (23).

So does that mean that we have to play Dow and O'Brien in place of Murphy?
Or perhaps we should play Williamson instead of Simpson?

Of course that is silly because the older players offer the team more.
Oh wait.
:-[

Why is Weitering above the law?