Who was better in 2011?

[kruddler]

Well if Ratten liked Murphy way more than Judd (not saying that was the case) that could have had a huge influence.

Murphy had a great year in 2011, far better than this year but Judd was on another level and is probably the prime reason why Murphy isn't as good anymore.

Weren't you trying to tell everyone how good Mitchell was by pointing to the AFLCA votes earlier this year?

You 'proved' Mitchell was better because he had more votes.

Even though Murphy polled in more games this year.
Perhaps Mitchell is very much liked by Al Clarkson since he had to justify his recruitment to the club.
Perhaps Bolton is very much an anti Murphy and should give him MORE votes.

Perhaps....just perhaps....you are fighting a losing battle and you should just accept that Murphy is a very good player who you have underrated.