08-26-2017, 09:29 AM
From the in-game thread...
From the first angle. Yes, agree.
From the second angle, doc was rolled (slightly) and Kennedy landed off to the side on his shoulder.
Casboult was 100% flat on his back.
I wouldn't be upset if the Doc one was paid, but if the roles were reversed, i'd be more unhappy if the tackle wasn't rewarded.
Quote:No, Docherty wasn't rolled. Rohan rode Docherty's back into the ground.
There's no difference between the tackles. If Rohan's tackle is a free kick, Casboult's should be too.
If I was umpiring, both tackles would result in a free for in the back.
From the first angle. Yes, agree.
From the second angle, doc was rolled (slightly) and Kennedy landed off to the side on his shoulder.
Casboult was 100% flat on his back.
I wouldn't be upset if the Doc one was paid, but if the roles were reversed, i'd be more unhappy if the tackle wasn't rewarded.